Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Oreo Pie
18. Mac & Cheese Pizza
Chicken Cesar Salad
Meatball Grinder
About
Pizza Mike's Pizzeria
If you're on the hunt for outstanding pizza in Storrs, CT, look no further than Pizza Mike's Pizzeria. Nestled conveniently within a gas station at 1659 Storrs Rd, this unexpected gem challenges preconceptions about where good food can be found. With a reputation for serving more than just your average takeout, Pizza Mike's is a treasure trove of flavors waiting to be explored.
What sets Pizza Mike's apart is their imaginative specialty pizzas. One standout is the Philly Cheesesteak Pizza, which combines seasoned steak with caramelized peppers, onions, and a medley of cheeses for a truly indulgent experience. If you’re seeking something unique, the Buffalo Chicken Pizza unites the bold flavors of buffalo sauce and mozzarella in a culinary dance that resonates with fans of spicy fare. Customers rave about the Philly Dave Pizza, adorned with a rich mayonnaise base and a layering of meats and cheese that excite the palate.
The reviews speak volumes about the satisfaction patrons derive from Pizza Mike's offerings. A regular diner wrote, "If you're in the mood for pizza, Mike has your pie!" This enthusiasm underlines the quality of the food, and the consensus suggests that each bite lives up to the hype. While some diners mentioned minor adjustments, like crust crispness, the overall experience reigns supreme — “every bite feels like a round of applause for your taste buds," one happy customer commented.
Dessert lovers will also be treated to a delightful selection. With indulgent options like the Molten Cake and the classic New York Cheesecake, it’s hard not to succumb to temptation. Priced reasonably, these desserts could be the perfect ending to your savory journey at Pizza Mike's.
Pizza Mike's Pizzeria is where flavor meets passion. It's not just pizza — it's an experience. With every visit, the cheerful owner, Mike, welcomes you like family, making the atmosphere as enjoyable as the food. So, whether you're grabbing a slice to go or savoring a pie in-house, rest assured that you've found yourself in a place that embraces both quality and community.
Remember, don't judge a book by its cover; Pizza Mike's Pizzeria is a brilliant example of how expectations can be flipped on their head. With a wide variety of available pizzas, delightful desserts, and friendly service, this pizzeria is a slice of paradise that promises good times and great food.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ This is a takeout review. All food is eaten fresh in the vehicle. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and a Margherita pizza. If I could I would rate this 4.5. It was good, plenty of cheese, garlic on the Margherita. But I felt the crust was undercooked and the sauce was just ok. On a scale from 0-10 I would rate this 7.8. It's a good score but a better crust would have put it over 8. ”
“ Their pizza is so good it should be illegal. Every time I go to a few other places and return to Pizza Mikes, I ask myself why I ever got pizza elsewhere. If you’re into Philly Steak pizzas, ask for the Philly Dave, you’ll be blown away. Worth every penny. ”
“ Best pizza around. If you're in the mood for pizza. Mike has your pie! Don't let the gas station fool you. This is absolutely not gas station pizza. It's a real pizza place the just happens to be in a gas station. I am a pizza snob and wouldn't eat subpar pie. I don't even write reviews normally but this pie it that good. I eat it weekly and it's constantly amazing pie ”
“ Delicious pizza. I love the potato pizza and they have some really funny flavors too. Nice sauce. Flavorful crust. ”
“ Although, I was hesitant for a second the location was at a gas station, it was the perfect atmosphere. The owner, Dave super great guy. Very cheerful and made such a banging cheese pizza with crunchy garlic crust. Never judge a book by it's cover, don't walk, but run into his pizza joint and get a good fresh pie. Eat right at the counter he will provide good business conversation. ”
“ Pizza mikes pizza is amazing. I had the Mediterranean pizza with chicken, the jalapeno pizza and the buf chick pizza and they were all very good ”
“ On 02/22 me and my son were in UConn and we chose to got to Pizza Mike’s gentleman who worked there was the nicest and most enthusiastic person I met in a while, we were there for a competition he not only enquired about the competition but shared his experience as a kid and asked us to even call and let him know about how competition went. Let me talk about Pizza, it was really good we ordered a cheese and veggie pizza and everyone in our group loved it :). To top everything my 10 year old told me that world needs more people like him :) ”
“ Fresh taste, balanced flavor, with a variety of options. Their large pizza, for 21, easily feeds three people; I really love their white based pizza. The staff are SUPER POLITE. I really recommend trying their food. Since they don't have that much of space to sit in, I personally prefer to take out their pizza for my parties. ”